Political and criminal law experts agree one thing is clear in the Conservative whodunnit that grips Ottawa: Simcoe-Grey, Ont., MP Helen Guergis has likely been destroyed politically and her reputation shredded, despite the absence so far of any trial, conviction, or even specific charges.
The machine-gun speed with which stunning allegations erupted over the past two weeks of alleged drug use by Ms. Guergis and her former-MP husband Rahim Jaffer, offshore bank accounts and sex play with "high class escorts" has prompted one of Canada's best-known political historians and a high-profile Toronto defence lawyer to accuse Prime Minister Stephen Harper (Calgary Southwest, Alta.) of not just rushing to judgment, but rocketing there.
"I think she's been convicted without trial," University of Toronto political scientist Peter Russell told The Hill Times.
And—according to news accounts and documents unearthed in the scandal's stampede last week—the sentence was based on the word of an obscure and bankrupt private eye whose only previous claim to fame was a short-lived Toronto Star story about his plan to evade several thousand dollars worth of fines for unpaid parking tickets.
"There has been a very significant rush to judgment in this case," said Frank Addario, immediate past president of the Criminal Lawyers Association. "The whiff of scandal has got everyone overheated. Everyone's perspective on this needs to be tempered by an understanding that her side of the story has yet to be told. It may turn out that the allegations are wildly inaccurate or baseless, or rooted on a completely unreliable source, or constructed."
Ottawa pollster Nik Nanos agrees that whatever happens—even if Ms.
